For the Person Who Keeps Sabotaging the Good Thing

Sagebrush Counseling

Reach out today to schedule a free 15-minute consult.

No intake forms, no commitment. We talk about what is going on and whether depth work is the right fit.

Schedule a Free 15-Min Consult About My Approach

LCMHC · LCPC · LPC · NH · ME · MT · TX · $200/session · No waitlist

People come to me describing a version of the same experience. They get close to something good, something they genuinely want, and then they do something to undermine it. They get the relationship and find reasons to push the person away. They build momentum toward a goal and find themselves inexplicably not doing the thing that would get them there. They get the opportunity and somehow miss it.

They usually arrive having already decided something unflattering about themselves: that they are afraid of success, or afraid of happiness, or fundamentally broken in some way that means they cannot have good things.

I want to offer a different frame. Not a more comfortable one, exactly, but a more accurate one, and one that points toward change.

In This Post

What self-sabotage is not
What it is
Why part of you works against the good thing
How it shows up
What depth work does with it

What Self-Sabotage Is Not

It is not weakness. The people who engage in self-sabotage most persistently are often not weak people. They are frequently high-functioning, self-aware, and genuinely motivated to change. They have often already tried willpower, accountability, positive thinking, behavioral strategies. The strategies have not worked, not because they lacked the discipline to apply them, but because discipline is not what is required for this particular problem.

It is not a character defect. There is nothing fundamentally wrong with the person who keeps getting in their own way. There is something operating in them that has a different agenda than the conscious goal, and that agenda is more powerful in the moment than the conscious intention.

It is not irrational, even when it looks irrational. The part that sabotages has its own logic. Understanding that logic is the beginning of working with it.

"Until you make the unconscious conscious, it will direct your life and you will call it fate." — Carl Jung

What It Is

Self-sabotage, from a depth psychology perspective, is a conflict between the conscious self and the unconscious. The conscious self wants the good thing. Part of the unconscious has reasons, which are not visible to the conscious mind, to prevent it.

This is not a poetic way of saying you are ambivalent. It is a description of how the psyche functions. The unconscious is not a passive storage unit for feelings you have put aside. It is an active part of the psyche with its own logic, its own priorities, and a significant amount of the psychological real estate that determines behavior. When its priorities conflict with the conscious agenda, the unconscious tends to win, not because it is more powerful in any simple sense, but because it is operating below the level of conscious override.

The behavior that looks like self-sabotage from the outside, and that feels like self-sabotage from the inside, is the unconscious doing exactly what it was organized to do. Understanding what it was organized to do, and why, is what makes change possible.

Why Part of You Works Against the Good Thing

There are several common dynamics underneath self-sabotage. They are not mutually exclusive and more than one may be operating simultaneously.

The good thing is not familiar, and familiar is safe

The unconscious is organized around what is known. What is known is safe, not because it is good, but because it is predictable. The good relationship, the success, the happiness, if it is genuinely new territory rather than a repetition of something already known, can be experienced by the unconscious as threatening rather than desirable, regardless of how consciously wanted it is.

This is why people sometimes find themselves more comfortable in difficulty than in ease. Difficulty is known. They have managed it before. The good thing is unfamiliar and the unfamiliar, however much the conscious mind wants it, can activate an unconscious protective response.

There is a belief about what you deserve

Beliefs about what we are entitled to, what we are worth, what we are allowed to have, are laid down early and often operate entirely outside conscious awareness. The person who consciously wants a loving relationship and unconsciously believes they do not deserve one will find ways to ensure the relationship fails, not because they want it to fail but because the unconscious is acting in accordance with a belief that the conscious mind cannot see and therefore cannot dispute.

These beliefs are not chosen. They are absorbed from early experience, from family dynamics, from the particular relational environment that shaped the developing self. Working with them requires reaching the layer where they are organized, which is not accessible through conscious reasoning alone.

The good thing threatens an important protection

Sometimes the self-sabotage is protecting something. The person who undermines relationships when they get serious may be protecting against the vulnerability of genuine intimacy, which at some earlier point felt dangerous. The person who sabotages success may be protecting against the exposure that success brings, or against a change in identity that success would require.

The protection was organized around a real threat. The threat may no longer be present. But the protection does not automatically dissolve when the threat is gone. It continues to operate until it is understood and consciously engaged with.

Part of you is organized around the absence of the good thing

This is perhaps the most counterintuitive dynamic, but it is one I see often. Some people have organized a significant part of their identity around not having the thing they say they want. The struggle itself has become meaningful. The longing has become part of who they are. Having the thing would dissolve a structure that, while painful, has become load-bearing.

This is not masochism. It is the psyche maintaining a form that it knows, even when that form is painful, because the alternative, not the good thing, but the dissolution of the known structure, feels more threatening than the continued absence of the good thing.

The part that keeps undoing it is workable

Self-sabotage is not a character flaw. It is unconscious material doing its job. Depth work changes that.

Individual therapy for people who are tired of getting in their own way. Fully virtual, NH, ME, MT, and TX.

Schedule a Free 15-Min Consult See All Services

No waitlist · Private pay · 100% virtual · $200 / session

How It Shows Up

Self-sabotage in practice takes many forms. Some of the most common:

Procrastination on high-stakes things only. The task that matters most gets avoided most persistently. Lower-stakes tasks get done. The avoidance is specific to what carries real meaning, which is a signal about what unconscious material is attached to it.
Picking fights or creating distance when a relationship deepens. As intimacy increases, so does the discomfort, and a conflict gets manufactured that creates distance and keeps the relationship at a manageable level of closeness.
Performing below capacity when it counts. Not a general performance problem, but a specific pattern of underperforming in situations with real stakes. The ordinary performance is fine. The important performance is where the unconscious resistance appears.
Leaving before being left. Ending things, or creating conditions that end things, before the other person can. The ending is self-generated but has the psychological function of preventing a different ending that would feel worse.
Proving the negative belief true. Acting in ways that confirm the belief that you are not worthy, not good enough, not capable of having the thing. The behavior looks self-defeating. It is consistent with a deeply held belief that the conscious mind cannot see.

What Depth Work Does With It

The approaches that do not work for self-sabotage are the ones that attempt to address it at the level of behavior or conscious motivation. More willpower. Better habits. Accountability structures. These can produce temporary change. The unconscious dynamic reasserts itself because it has not been addressed.

Depth work goes to the level where the sabotage is organized. In practice this involves several things.

Getting curious about the part that sabotages

Rather than treating the sabotaging behavior as an enemy to be overcome, depth work treats it as a communication. What is the behavior protecting? What is it organized around? What would happen, in the logic of the unconscious, if the sabotage did not occur and the good thing was had?

These questions sound simple. The answers are often not obvious, and not available through direct reflection. They emerge over time in a good therapeutic relationship, often indirectly, through what comes up when the topic is approached from different angles.

Working with the belief that underlies it

The belief about what you deserve, or what is safe, or what is allowed, is not changed by being told the belief is wrong. It is changed by the accumulated experience of something different, over time, in a relational context that provides new evidence about what is possible. The therapeutic relationship is one of the primary places where this new evidence is generated.

Making room for the good thing

Part of what depth work does is create the internal conditions under which the good thing becomes something the psyche can hold. Not just want, but tolerate having. The conscious wanting was always there. What changes is the unconscious infrastructure that was preventing the wanting from becoming having.

If you are in New Hampshire, Maine, Montana, or Texas, I work with people on exactly this. See therapy in New Hampshire, therapy in Maine, therapy in Montana, or therapy in Texas. For more on the approach, see the Jungian therapist page.

✦ ✦ ✦

Questions I Often Hear

Is this just fear of success?+

Fear of success is one of the dynamics that can underlie self-sabotage, but it is rarely the complete picture and it is often not the most accurate description. What tends to be more accurate is that success, or the good relationship, or the good thing, is threatening for a specific reason: it is unfamiliar, it conflicts with a belief about what is deserved, it threatens a protection, or it would require a change in identity that the psyche is not yet ready to make. Naming it as fear of success can make it harder to work with because it stops the inquiry before it reaches what is specifically generating the behavior.

Does this mean I unconsciously want bad things to happen to me?+

No. The part that sabotages does not want you to suffer. It is protecting against something it regards as threatening. The protection happens to look self-destructive from the outside, and it is self-defeating in terms of the conscious goal, but it has its own logic that is not about wanting harm. Understanding that logic, rather than treating the behavior as evidence of a death wish or masochism, is what makes it workable.

Why can't I just decide to stop doing it?+

Because the behavior is generated below the level of conscious decision. Deciding to stop is a conscious act. The behavior originates in the unconscious, which does not update in response to conscious decisions. This is why willpower consistently fails for self-sabotage: the force generating the behavior is not accessible to the faculty being deployed against it. What reaches it is a different kind of engagement entirely.

How long does it take to change this?+

It depends on how deep the pattern is, how long it has been operating, and what it is organized around. Some people notice meaningful shift within a few months of consistent depth work. The more entrenched the pattern, the longer the work tends to take. What I typically see is that the behavior becomes visible in real time before it becomes less frequent, which is itself a significant change, there is a pause between the activation and the action that was not there before. See the FAQs for more on how sessions work practically.

What if the sabotage happens in relationships specifically?+

Relational self-sabotage is particularly common and particularly well-suited to depth work, because the relational pattern tends to appear in the therapeutic relationship itself, where it can be examined directly rather than just described. If the same dynamic keeps appearing across different relationships, see also the post on when the same pattern keeps showing up.

Sagebrush Counseling

You are not broken. Something in you is trying to protect you. Let's find out what.

A free 15-minute consult to talk through what is going on and whether this is the right fit.

Schedule a Free 15-Min Consult About Sagebrush Counseling

LCMHC · LCPC · LPC · NH · ME · MT · TX · No waitlist

✦ ✦ ✦