Is It Cheating—or a Misunderstanding?

The word “cheating” carries so much weight. For many, it instantly brings up feelings of betrayal, heartbreak, and fear. But in real life, relationships are rarely that black-and-white. What one partner experiences as infidelity, the other may see as a misunderstanding, a boundary that was never clearly defined, or an innocent interaction taken the wrong way.

As a therapist, I’ve seen this tension unfold in countless couples. The pain on one side is real. The surprise or defensiveness on the other is real, too. And often, both partners are right—at least from their perspective. Understanding where these differences come from is the first step toward healing.

Unsure If It’s Cheating or Just a Misunderstanding?

If trust feels shaken, you don’t have to figure it out alone. Therapy can help you and your partner define boundaries, rebuild safety, and move forward together.

Schedule Your Consultation

Why Couples See Cheating So Differently

Cheating isn’t a universal concept. Some people see it strictly as sexual contact outside of the relationship. For others, it includes emotional closeness, flirting, or even private conversations with someone who feels like a threat.

This is why two people can be in the same relationship but live with very different definitions of betrayal. Without talking openly about boundaries, assumptions take over—and assumptions are fragile. More reading on betrayal: Can’t Stop Checking Their Phone? Why It Happens After Betrayal

When Feeling Betrayed Doesn’t Match Their Intent

One of the most painful dynamics couples bring into therapy is this:

• One partner feels devastated and certain they’ve been cheated on.

• The other insists they didn’t cross a line and can’t understand why it’s being treated as infidelity.

Maybe someone kept a dating profile “just to browse.” Maybe there were late-night texts with a coworker. Maybe an old flame was contacted on social media. To the partner who feels hurt, it can feel like a breach of trust. To the partner who did it, it may feel harmless or even accidental.

This mismatch doesn’t mean one person is lying. It means the couple is bumping up against different definitions of what loyalty looks like. More infidelity reading: Daily Habits That Strengthen Trust Before It’s Broken and How Do You Know If You Should Stay or Go After Infidelity?

When Secrets Feel Like Betrayal

Again and again, I’ve seen that it’s not always the behavior itself that creates the deepest wound—it’s the secrecy around it.

• A dinner with a coworker isn’t automatically cheating. Hiding it might be.

• Messaging an old friend doesn’t always signal betrayal. Lying about it might.

Secrecy erodes trust because it signals: I don’t feel safe being transparent with you. That’s often more damaging than the event itself.

Research supports this too. A study published in the Journal of Social and Personal Relationships found that secrecy itself often harms trust more than the specific behavior, because it signals a lack of openness and safety in the relationship.

How Misunderstandings About Infidelity Take Root

Misunderstandings don’t come out of nowhere. They usually grow out of:

• Different backgrounds. Family, culture, and previous relationships all shape what counts as betrayal.

• Unspoken assumptions. Couples often believe they’re on the same page without ever saying out loud what “cheating” means to them.

• Technology’s blurred lines. Social media, texting, and dating apps create new gray areas. Is “liking” a flirtatious post a betrayal? What about having a secret chat thread?

Without ongoing dialogue, these differences can turn small disconnects into full-blown conflict.

Talking About Boundaries Before Trust Gets Broken

The healthiest couples I work with aren’t the ones who never face temptation or misunderstanding—they’re the ones who talk about it openly.

• Define boundaries together. Ask each other: What feels like cheating to you? What feels safe?

• Share past experiences. If you’ve been betrayed before, let your partner know why certain actions hit harder.

• Agree on transparency, not policing. Openness should feel mutual and respectful, not controlling.

• Check in regularly. Boundaries aren’t one-time conversations. They evolve with your relationship.

Turning Misunderstandings Into Deeper Connection

When couples face these painful moments, it can feel like the beginning of the end. But I often see the opposite. Misunderstandings can be turning points.

When partners choose to lean in—to really listen, to validate each other’s feelings, to clarify expectations—what started as a fracture can become an opening for deeper intimacy.

It’s not about labeling the situation once and for all as “cheating” or “not cheating.” It’s about asking: What did this mean to you? What do we want our relationship to stand for? How can we make sure this doesn’t happen again?

Choosing Healing Over Labels

At the end of the day, what matters most isn’t whether the moment gets labeled as “cheating” or “a misunderstanding.” What matters is how you both respond to the hurt. Trust may feel shaken, but it isn’t gone forever.

This can be an opportunity to pause, reflect, and decide what kind of relationship you want to build moving forward. With honesty, clarity, and willingness to repair, misunderstandings can become stepping stones to greater intimacy. And even if betrayal has occurred, healing is possible when both partners commit to showing up differently.

The question isn’t just “Was it cheating?” The deeper invitation is: “How can we learn from this, rebuild safety, and strengthen our bond so it lasts?”

Rebuild Trust and Find Clarity

Whether it was cheating or a misunderstanding, healing is possible. Take the first step toward clarity and connection today.

Contact Sagebrush Counseling

Frequently Asked Questions

What counts as cheating in a relationship?

For some, it means physical intimacy outside the relationship. For others, it includes emotional closeness, secret texting, or flirting online. What matters is how you and your partner define betrayal together—and whether those boundaries are respected.

Why do couples see cheating so differently?

Different life experiences, cultural backgrounds, and past relationships shape how each partner views infidelity. Without clear communication, these differences often lead to misunderstandings and hurt.

Is keeping secrets the same as cheating?

Not always—but secrecy often causes as much harm as the act itself. Even if the behavior seems small, hiding it can create deep mistrust. Couples usually find that transparency matters more than perfection.

How do we prevent misunderstandings about cheating?

The best prevention is open dialogue. Talk early and often about what feels safe, what feels like betrayal, and what helps you both feel secure. Revisiting these conversations as your relationship grows can stop small misunderstandings from becoming major ruptures.

Can therapy help if one of us feels betrayed but the other says it was a misunderstanding?

Yes. Therapy creates a safe space to unpack both perspectives, validate the hurt, and clarify boundaries. With guidance, couples can move from defensiveness toward repair and a stronger foundation of trust.