ARFID vs. Picky Eating in Adults: How to Tell the Difference
Is it just being selective, or something more? Understanding ARFID in adults and its surprising connections to neurodivergence.
You know that friend who always orders the same thing at restaurants? Or maybe you've noticed your own eating patterns becoming increasingly restrictive over the years. While many adults dismiss this as simply being "picky," emerging research reveals a more complex picture—one that connects eating patterns to neurodivergence in ways we're only beginning to understand.
Avoidant/Restrictive Food Intake Disorder (ARFID) affects far more adults than previously recognized, and recent studies show striking connections to autism, ADHD, and sensory processing differences. Let's explore what sets ARFID apart from typical picky eating and why understanding these connections matters for your wellbeing.
If you’re looking for counseling for autism couples therapy or neurodiverse couples therapy- we offer both at our practice.
When "Picky" Becomes Problematic: The ARFID Difference
The line between picky eating and ARFID isn't always clear, but the impact tells the story. While picky eaters might avoid mushrooms or prefer their food prepared certain ways, people with ARFID experience eating restrictions so severe they interfere with their health, relationships, and daily life.
Picky eating typically involves:
Avoiding specific foods while maintaining overall nutrition
Being able to try new foods, even if reluctantly
Food preferences that don't significantly impact social situations
Stable weight and energy levels
ARFID, however, is characterized by:
Severe food restrictions based on texture, smell, taste, or appearance
Significant weight loss or inability to maintain healthy weight
Nutritional deficiencies that affect physical health
Intense anxiety around eating or trying new foods
Social isolation due to food-related fears
Reliance on supplements instead of varied food sources
The key difference? ARFID isn't about wanting to lose weight or concerns about body image—it's about genuine distress, fear, or physical inability to consume adequate nutrition.
The Neurodivergent Brain and Food: A Complex Relationship
Here's where the plot thickens: groundbreaking research from 2024-2025 reveals that ARFID and neurodivergence are deeply intertwined. Among children with ARFID, those with the condition were 14 times more likely to have autism and nine times more likely to have ADHD than children without ARFID.
But why does this connection exist? The answer lies in how neurodivergent brains process sensory information.
The Sensory Sensitivity Connection
Recent research with gender diverse adults found that when accounting for autistic and ADHD traits, sensory hyper-sensitivity had the strongest association with ARFID symptoms. This suggests that heightened sensory processing—a hallmark of many neurodivergent conditions—may be a key driver of food avoidance.
For neurodivergent individuals, food isn't just about taste. It's a complex sensory experience involving:
Texture sensitivity: The feeling of food in the mouth can be overwhelming
Smell aversion: Certain food odors may trigger intense discomfort
Visual processing: The appearance of food can evoke strong reactions
Sound sensitivity: Even the sound of certain foods being eaten can be distressing
Temperature sensitivity: Foods that are too hot or cold may be intolerable
The ADHD Factor
People with ADHD face unique challenges around eating that can contribute to ARFID development:
Executive functioning difficulties: Planning and preparing varied meals requires significant cognitive resources
Hyperfocus tendencies: Getting intensely focused on specific "safe" foods
Sensory seeking or avoiding: Either craving intense flavors or being overwhelmed by them
Medication effects: ADHD medications can suppress appetite, potentially worsening restrictive eating patterns
The Surprising Rise of Adult ARFID
ARFID had a prevalence rate of 0.13% in 2023, though this is likely underestimated, and rates in adults are climbing. Several factors contribute to this increase:
Delayed Recognition: Many adults with ARFID went undiagnosed in childhood when awareness was limited. The disorder was only officially recognized in the DSM-5 in 2013.
Increased Neurodivergent Diagnoses: As more adults receive autism and ADHD diagnoses, the connection to eating difficulties becomes apparent.
Stress and Life Changes: Adult stressors can exacerbate existing sensitivities or trigger new food aversions.
Diet Culture Influence: Restrictive dieting practices may increase vulnerability to developing ARFID, especially in neurodivergent individuals.
What ARFID Isn't
Myth 1: "It's just being dramatic or attention-seeking" Reality: ARFID causes genuine distress and has measurable physical consequences. No one chooses to restrict their eating to the point of malnutrition or social isolation.
Myth 2: "Adults should just grow out of it" Reality: Unlike childhood picky eating, ARFID typically requires professional intervention and doesn't resolve on its own.
Myth 3: "It's the same as anorexia" Reality: ARFID has nothing to do with body image or weight concerns. The restriction is based on sensory, fear, or interest factors.
Myth 4: "It only affects children" Reality: While often beginning in childhood, ARFID can persist into adulthood or develop at any age.
Hope and Healing: Treatment Approaches That Work
The good news? ARFID is treatable, and understanding the neurodivergent connection has led to more effective, compassionate approaches.
Evidence-Based Treatments Include:
Cognitive Behavioral Therapy for ARFID (CBT-AR): This specialized approach helps individuals understand and gradually challenge their food-related fears and avoidances while developing coping strategies.
Exposure and Response Prevention: Gradual, supported exposure to feared foods in a safe therapeutic environment, designed specifically for neurodivergent sensory needs.
Sensory-Based Interventions: Working with occupational therapists to understand and accommodate sensory differences while gradually expanding food tolerance.
Medication Support: While there's no specific medication for ARFID, treating co-occurring anxiety or ADHD can significantly help the eating disorder recovery process.
The Neurodiversity-Affirming Approach
Modern ARFID treatment increasingly embraces neurodiversity-affirming principles:
Respecting sensory differences rather than trying to eliminate them
Building on individual strengths and interests
Creating accommodations rather than forcing conformity
Understanding that some level of food selectivity may always exist—and that's okay
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Can adults develop ARFID, or does it always start in childhood? A: While ARFID often begins in childhood, it can develop at any age. Adult onset may be triggered by medical issues, trauma, increased stress, or newly recognized neurodivergent traits.
Q: Is it possible to have ARFID without being neurodivergent? A: Yes, though neurodivergence significantly increases risk. ARFID can develop due to medical conditions, trauma, or other factors unrelated to neurodivergence.
Q: How long does treatment take? A: Treatment duration varies widely depending on severity, individual factors, and treatment approach. Some people see improvement in weeks, while others may need months or years of support.
Q: Will I ever be able to eat "normally"? A: Recovery looks different for everyone. Many people significantly expand their food repertoire and reduce distress around eating, though some level of selectivity may remain—and that's perfectly valid.
Q: Can ARFID cause serious health problems? A: Yes, untreated ARFID can lead to malnutrition, weight loss, vitamin deficiencies, and social isolation. Early intervention is crucial for preventing these complications.
Q: How do I know if my eating habits warrant professional help? A: Consider seeking support if your eating patterns cause significant distress, interfere with your health or social life, or if you're relying heavily on supplements to meet nutritional needs.
Q: Is there a connection between ARFID and other mental health conditions? A: Yes, ARFID commonly co-occurs with anxiety, depression, OCD, autism, and ADHD. Treating these conditions alongside ARFID often improves outcomes.
Moving Forward: Your Next Steps
If you recognize yourself in this description, you're not alone—and more importantly, you're not broken. ARFID is a legitimate medical condition that responds well to appropriate treatment, especially when neurodivergent traits are understood and accommodated.
Signs it might be time to seek support:
Your food restrictions are impacting your health, energy, or weight
You avoid social situations because of food-related anxiety
You spend significant mental energy worrying about food or meal planning
Family or friends have expressed concern about your eating habits
You rely primarily on supplements rather than varied foods
You suspect you might be neurodivergent and are experiencing eating difficulties
Remember: Seeking help for eating difficulties doesn't mean you're weak or dramatic. It means you're taking charge of your health and wellbeing.
Take the First Step Toward Food Freedom
At Sagebrush Counseling, we understand the complex relationship between neurodivergence and eating patterns. Our trauma-informed, neurodiversity-affirming approach recognizes that your brain works differently—and that's not something to fix, but something to understand and work with.
We specialize in helping adults navigate:
ARFID and selective eating challenges
The intersection of neurodivergence and eating concerns
Sensory processing differences that impact daily life
Building sustainable coping strategies that honor your unique needs
Ready to explore whether ARFID treatment could help you?
Contact Sagebrush Counseling today to schedule a consultation. Our experienced team will help you understand your eating patterns, explore potential connections to neurodivergence, and develop a personalized treatment plan that respects your individual needs and goals.
Your relationship with food doesn't have to be a source of stress. Let's work together to find a path forward that honors both your neurological differences and your right to nourishment and joy around eating.
This blog post is for educational purposes only and does not constitute medical or therapeutic advice. If you're experiencing symptoms of ARFID or other eating concerns, please consult with qualified healthcare professionals for proper assessment and treatment.
